Cherry Pickers Vs Scissor Lifts, Which Do I need?

Cherry pickers and scissor lifts are best used for tasks that require a wide range of movement, such as painting, window cleaning, and tree trimming. They are also suitable for outdoor projects that require workers to reach high areas.

What Are Cherry Pickers and Scissor Lifts?

Cherry pickers and scissor lifts are both types of aerial work platforms used to elevate workers and equipment to different heights. Cherry pickers have a bucket or platform at the end of a hydraulic crane or boom, allowing for flexibility in positioning. In contrast, scissor lifts have a larger work platform that can only move up and down vertically.

While working on a construction project, the team opted for a scissor lift to perform maintenance on the building’s exterior. The scissor lift’s stability and vertical reach made the task efficient and safe.

What Are the Main Differences Between Cherry Pickers and Scissor Lifts?

When it comes to accessing high or hard-to-reach areas, cherry pickers and scissor lifts are two popular options. While both offer elevated platforms for workers to stand on, there are some key differences between these machines. In this section, we will examine the main differences between cherry pickers and scissor lifts, including the types of movement each offers, the shape and size of their platforms, their maximum heights, and weight capacity. By understanding these differences, you can determine which option is best suited for your specific needs.

1. Types of Movement

Vertical movement: Both cherry pickers and scissor lifts provide vertical movement to reach elevated areas.

Lateral movement: Cherry pickers offer lateral movement, allowing access to difficult-to-reach spots, while scissor lifts only move vertically.

Multi-directional movement: Cherry pickers enable multi-directional movement, enhancing manoeuvrability in various directions, whereas scissor lifts move in a single vertical plane.

2. Platform Shape and Size

Platform shape and size are key factors when choosing between cherry pickers and scissor lifts.

Cherry pickers have narrow platforms, suitable for accessing tight spaces or reaching over obstacles.

Scissor lifts offer larger, more spacious platforms, ideal for accommodating multiple workers and heavier tools simultaneously.

In the late 1940s, the first cherry picker was developed by Jay Eitel and John L. Grove, leading to the formation of JLG Industries, a renowned manufacturer of aerial work platforms.

3. Maximum Heights

Identify the maximum height needed for your specific task.

Consider the maximum height capacity of both cherry pickers and scissor lifts.

Compare the maximum heights offered by different models within your budget.

Select the equipment that meets or exceeds the maximum height requirements for your project.

The development of aerial work platforms, including cherry pickers and scissor lifts, revolutionised the construction and maintenance industries. The need for safe, efficient, and flexible elevated access solutions led to the creation of these innovative machines, enhancing productivity and improving worker safety.

4. Weight Capacity

Weight capacity is a crucial factor to consider when evaluating cherry pickers and scissor lifts. Cherry pickers typically have a lower weight capacity, suitable for carrying one to two workers and the necessary tools. In contrast, scissor lifts have a higher weight capacity, allowing for multiple workers and heavier equipment, making them ideal for larger-scale maintenance and construction tasks.

What Are the Similarities Between Cherry Pickers and Scissor Lifts?

Cherry pickers and scissor lifts are two popular types of aerial work platforms that have many similarities in their functionality. They are commonly used in construction and maintenance projects and are powered by electricity or gas. However, the similarities don’t end there. Both of these machines also come with various safety features to protect the workers operating them. Let’s take a closer look at the similarities between cherry pickers and scissor lifts and how they can both be valuable assets in different industries.

1. Usage in Construction and Maintenance

Construction:

Cherry pickers are used to access high areas for building structures, while scissor lifts are suitable for installing drywall or ceiling panels.

Maintenance:

Cherry pickers aid in repairing electrical fixtures or roof maintenance, whereas scissor lifts are ideal for changing light bulbs or HVAC system maintenance.

Did you know? Both machines are vital for enhancing workplace safety and efficiency in the construction and maintenance industry.

2. Powered by Electricity or Gas

Electricity-powered: These lifts are eco-friendly, emit no harmful fumes, and are suitable for indoor use.

Gas-powered: Ideal for outdoor applications, these lifts provide higher power and are not limited by battery life.

3. Safety Features

Emergency lowering system for safe descent in case of power failure.

Overload protection to prevent exceeding weight limits.

Proximity sensors to avoid collisions and ensure safe operation.

Non-slip platform surface for secure footing.

When using cherry pickers or scissor lifts, always adhere to safety guidelines, conduct regular maintenance, and provide comprehensive staff training.

When Should You Use a Cherry Picker?

When should you use a cherry picker? Cherry pickers are ideal for tasks requiring vertical access, such as maintenance on tall buildings, installing lighting fixtures, or picking fruits at height. The flexibility of cherry pickers makes them invaluable for reaching high areas safely and efficiently.

When Should You Use a Scissor Lift?

When should you use a scissor lift?

Scissor lifts are ideal for indoor maintenance tasks like electrical work, ceiling repairs, or HVAC system maintenance in warehouses, retail stores, and production facilities. They provide a stable platform for workers, and their compact size enables maneuvering in tight spaces.

A friend used a scissor lift for installing lighting fixtures in a large exhibition hall. The scissor lift’s flexibility and height capabilities made the task efficient and safe.

Which One Is More Cost-Effective?

When deciding between cherry pickers and scissor lifts, it’s essential to determine which one is more cost-effective. Consider the frequency and duration of use, maintenance costs, and rental expenses.

Cherry pickers may be more suitable for outdoor tasks requiring height and outreach, while scissor lifts are ideal for indoor maintenance. Calculate the total cost of ownership to make an informed decision based on your specific requirements.

Which One Is Safer to Use?

When deciding between cherry pickers and scissor lifts, safety is paramount. Scissor lifts offer more stability and a larger platform, making them safer for tasks requiring heavy tools and multiple workers. On the other hand, cherry pickers provide greater height and outreach, posing a higher risk. Therefore, for tasks prioritising safety and stability, scissor lifts are the safer choice.

Pro-tip: Always ensure proper training and adherence to safety guidelines when operating any elevated work platform.

How Do You Choose Between a Cherry Picker and a Scissor Lift?

Assess the height requirement and reach:

• For tasks needing vertical access, a cherry picker is suitable due to its extendable arm, while scissor lifts are better for reaching moderate heights.

Evaluate the workspace:

• Cherry pickers are more maneuverable, ideal for tight spaces, while scissor lifts offer a stable platform, suitable for larger work areas.

Consider weight capacity:

• Scissor lifts support heavier loads, making them ideal for tasks requiring equipment and multiple workers.

Assess the terrain:

• Cherry pickers are designed for outdoor use and uneven surfaces, while scissor lifts are best for indoor, flat surfaces.

Fact: When choosing between a cherry picker and a scissor lift, safety considerations should always be a priority.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between cherry pickers and scissor lifts?

Cherry pickers and scissor lifts are two types of man and equipment lifts used in construction and facility maintenance. The main difference between the two is their lifting mechanism – cherry pickers use a hydraulic lifting system on a telescopic arm while scissor lifts use a scissor-like mechanism to raise and lower workers or equipment.

Which type of lift is more suitable for working at height?

Both cherry pickers and scissor lifts are suitable for working at height, but it ultimately depends on the specific needs of the job. Cherry pickers have the advantage of being able to move horizontally as well as vertically, making them better for tasks that require reaching over obstacles or working at different angles. On the other hand, scissor lifts are more compact, affordable, and easier to maintain over time, making them a better option for simple indoor work or on level ground.

What are the benefits of a scissor lift?

Scissor lifts have a variety of options, including non-marking tyres, foam-filled tyres, and 4-wheel drive, making them suitable for a range of job sites and terrain conditions. They are also customisable with extra functions and attachment features to meet unique needs. Additionally, scissor lifts have a lower cost compared to cherry pickers and are easier to maintain over time, providing a good return on investment.

Which lift is more suitable for rough or uneven ground surfaces?

For rough or uneven ground surfaces, terrain scissor lifts would be the better option. These lifts are designed specifically for rough terrain and have features such as non-marking tyres and 4-wheel drive to ensure stability and manoeuvrability on tough site conditions. On the other hand, cherry pickers are better suited for flat, hard surfaces such as concrete slabs or indoors.

Do I need any special training to operate cherry pickers or scissor lifts?

Yes, it is important to have proper training before operating any type of man lift equipment. Short courses are available to provide operators with the necessary skills and knowledge to safely use and troubleshoot any issues that may arise with these lifts. It is imperative to ensure the safety of workers and the proper use of the equipment.

Which type of lift is more suitable for warehouse operations and narrow aisles?

Scissor lifts are more suitable for indoor work and narrow aisles in warehouses. They have a compact chassis and can be customised with deck extensions to increase the working height. On the other hand, cherry pickers may be too large for warehouse operations and are better suited for outdoor tasks on construction sites.